Episodes

In this episode Ashley details the criminal history of Jesse McFadden, the man responsible for the Henryetta mass murder. Once you learn about his history you too will be left wondering how in the hell was this man free to walk around and why was he allowed around these children. Part 2 will cover Holly's history and the actual tragedy. Resources: 1. Body of Crime: Henryetta Mass Murders: Monster- Jesse Lee McFadden 2. https://kfor.com/news/local/unchecked-sin-required-checks-for-jesse-mcfadden...

We can't respond, so if you have specific questions, message us on FB! Welcome to Part 2 of the Long Island Serial Killer (LISK) or the Gilgo Beach Killer story, and we are joined again by Sarah Sarah! This is a HUGE & WILD story - but it's important to remind everyone that we want to honor the victims & their loved ones of this case. With that being said, this episode starts with the discovery that an architect named Rex Huermann is allegedly responsible for the deaths of so many of the victim...

We can't respond, so if you have specific questions, message us on FB! This week, Kat and Ashley are joined by Sarah Sarah! (FInally!) Kat kicks off a two-part series on the gripping investigation into the Long Island Serial Killer (LISK) and his eventual capture after decades of eluding justice. Grab a drink, because the story is intense. From a corrupt police force to the neglect of the victims' stories, this case is brimming with drama and dark twists. PS. If you messaged us about the Brian...

Have something you want to say? Text us! Join us this week as Ashley tells us about the disappearance and murder of Sierah Joughim that led investigators to discover a barn of horrors. Even though the case has a heartbreaking ending, her family turned this tragedy into a lot of positivity which we discuss towards the end of the episode. Join us as we explore the dark side of humanity. Resources: 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Sierah_Joughin 2. https://courtnewsohio.gov/cases/2021/S...

Have something you want to say? Text us! Grab a beer and join us as Kat talks to us about the tragic and brutal murder of Mary Anne Holmes, a 29-year-old single mother who was violently attacked in her own home in Thatcher, Arizona. On the night of July 9th, 1995, an unknown assailant broke into Mary Anne's house, subjecting her to unspeakable horrors while her two young daughters were present. We'll explore the details of that fateful night, the investigation that followed, and the lasting impa...

Have something you want to say? Text us! This week Ashley discusses the frustrating disappearance case of Christopher Thompkins, a 20 year old African-American man from Georgia. He was with 3 coworkers when they claim they looked away from him for a few seconds and then he was 'mysteriously' gone. Help us keep his name alive. Join us as we explore the dark side of humanity! Anyone with any information on the whereabouts of Christopher Carlton Thompkins is asked to contact the Harris County Sher...

Have something you want to say? Text us! It's Part 2 of Kat's deep dive into the Synanon cult, and it gets really WILD really quickly. So, hang on to your hats, folks. REFERENCES: THE DOC: The Synanon Fix | Official Website for the HBO Original | HBO.com THE PODCAST: The Sunshine Place on Apple Podcasts The Cult of Synanon | SC S04E02 Part I (youtube.com) Former Synanon child's photos: (682) Pinterest Synanon - Wikipedia Home - It's Time for Morning Meeting (synanon.com) The Cult That Spawned t...

Have something you want to say? Text us! Join us this week as Kat kicks off Part 1 of her deep dive into Synanon – a drug rehabilitation program turned cult that began in the late 1950s and eventually inspired the troubled teen industry. In this first episode, we explore the early, seemingly positive days of Synanon – you might even feel tempted to join! But beware, the journey ahead is filled with wild twists and turns! REFERENCES: THE DOC: The Synanon Fix | Official Website for the HBO Origin...

Have something you want to say? Text us! In this week's episode, Ashley tells us about Poveglia Island, the most haunted island on the planet, also described as the most evil place on earth. We discuss the history of the island, the deaths that occurred and all the paranormal activity. Join us as we explore the dark side of humanity! Resources: 1. https://thelittlehouseofhorrors.com/poveglia-island/ 2. https://greekreporter.com/2023/11/17/poveglia-most-haunted-place/ 3. https://vocal.media/horr...

Have something you want to say? Text us! In this episode, Ashley discusses the tragic deaths of Blake and Mary-Jo Hadley. Tyler Hadley, 17 at the time, wanted to throw a party and was upset with his parents so he decided to murder them. Join us as we discuss the events leading up to the incident, the absolute trash that was at the party, and then the aftermath. Join us as we explore the dark side of humanity. Resources: 1. https://www.tcpalm.com/story/news/crime/st-lucie-county/2018/09/28/who-t...

It's a story most of you know about. But with the trial of Chad Daybell starting this past month, it begs for a refresher! This week, Kat takes us through the Lori Vallow Daybell saga; from extramarital affairs to zombies. And you might learn some new things about this case! References: Sins of Our Mother - Netflix Mommy Doomsday on Apple Podcasts Inside the Lori Vallow Daybell Trial from 48 Hours on Apple Podcasts Court TV Phone Call Idaho jurors see graphic photos of slain kids in Lori Vallow...

This one is a doozie, folks! Kat and Ashley are visited by their friend, Oleksandr, who requested this story and was "voluntold" to help with pronunciation! This week, Kat covers a man that was known as "The Red Ripper," the "Rostov Ripper," and the "Butcher of Rostov..." That's right, Kat is covering Andrei Chikatilo, one of the worst serial killers in the world. So, grab a drink and buckle up...this is going to be a wild ride. LOTS OF TRIGGER WARNINGS: Sexual assault, sexual assault against m...

This week's episode is all about Angel's Landing, a cult formed my a man named Lou who claimed to be possessed by three angels, could cure diseases, predict when people were going to die and also bring people back from the dead. When members kept mysteriously dying as Lou got richer, a 9 year investigation would begin. Join us as we explore the dark side of humanity... TW: sexual abuse of minors; physical abuse of minors Resources: *will be added soon*

This week, Kat does an overview of where we are NOW with the whole Ruby Franke/8 Passenger/Jodi Hildebrandt child abuse saga. Lots of evidence was recently released and Kat went through it ALL. Some newer updates (like from just this week!) have also come out, so once you listen, you will be all caught up. This is Case Files, so there's ALWAYS a standing Trigger Warning. But, with this one, we will discuss child abuse. Please listen carefully. References: The Rise and Fall of Ruby Franke | Won...

In this episode Ashley discusses the murder of Jackie Vandagriff in September 2016. The events that lead up to this murder are truly terrifying and highlights the real dangers of stalking, especially by former romantic partners. If you are being stalked, please reach out to your local resources and get help-- stalking is real, it's dangerous and escalates very quickly. We are here for you if you need us. Resources: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/jackie-vandagriff-murder-targeted-killer-ex-48-hour...

In this week's episode, Kat brings us the horrific tale of the death of the Reading Man, Warren Barnes, at the hands of 19-year- old, Brian Cohee, Jr. What's strange, is how this tale unfolds, how his parents are the ones who called 911, and how quickly the community reacted. Thanks to Explore With Us for putting all of the police footage together for this bizarre story. Follow them on YouTube! Thanks to The Wizard for finding this story for us! Grab a drink, tune in, and explore the dark side...

In this episode, Ashley discusses William Paul Smolinski, Jr, often referred to by his nickname Billy, who went missing in August 2004. While initially, law enforcement thought he left on his own, foul play is now suspected. “We are never going to give up searching for our son,” Janice said. “We are driven by our faith, and all the mistakes and obstacles we’ve encountered make us more determined to find the truth and bring Billy home.” Resources: 1. https://www.nbcconnecticut.com/news/local/mur...

The '70s were coming to an end when a babe in the woods named Dorothy Hoogstratten (later shortened to Stratten) was "discovered" by a sleazy hustler and pimp, Paul Sider, at a Dairy Queen in Vancouver, British Columbia. What follows is a brief, whirlwind of a tale about love, control, stardom, and life at Playboy. Grab your drink and join Kat as you hear all about the ingenue who inspired movies like Star 80 and could have been the next Marilyn Monroe. Come and explore the dark side of humanit...

In this week's episode, Ashley talks about the 1977 murder of 3 Girl Scouts at Camp Scott in Oklahoma. She discusses who they were, the camp itself and the crazy roller coaster of an investigation. Let's never forget about Lori Farmer, Michele Guse and Denise Milner. Join us as we explore the dark side of humanity... Resources: 1. https://www.ranker.com/list/oklahoma-girl-scout-murders/cat-mcauliffe 2. https://www.oklahoman.com/story/news/columns/2017/06/14/girl-scout-murders-in-oklahoma-remain...

We're back! Thanks for your patience; Kat was trying to be a (good) Mom for a bit. This week, Kat brings us the short but interesting story of Cowboy Bob. Heard of him? No? Grab a drink, hitch your horse up, settle in, and join us this week for a pretty interesting story. References: https://www.texasmonthly.com/true-crime/the-last-ride-of-cowboy-bob/ https://thisiscriminal.com/episode-140-cowboy-bob-5-15-2020/ https://www.spokesman.com/stories/2005/may/06/bank-robber-shot-dead-in-texas/

In this week's episode, Ashley tells us about Jacob Cabinaw, a man from Michigan, who by all accounts seemed like an attentive father, a hardworking employee and an overall great person. One night he randomly headed towards Texas without telling anyone why or where he was headed. He was never seen from again. If you have any information about Jacob’s disappearance, please call the Grand Traverse County Sheriff’s Department at 231-995-5002, send an email to info@gtsheriff.org or contact unsolved...

***TRIGGER WARNING FOR SEXUAL ASSAULT AND DOMESTIC VIOLENCE*** This week, Kat tells us about a serial rapist there isn't a lot of information on - James Bergstrom. Thanks to his (now ex) wife, he is sitting in jail and the streets of Houston are a bit safer. This story was actually so close to home it's scary! References: 1. Amazon.com: Evil Beside Her: The True Story of a Texas Woman's Marriage to a Dangerous Psychopath: 9780061582011: Casey, Kathryn: Books 2. Evil Lives Here (2022) "He Tied ...

Boy is this story a roller coaster! Truly went down a rabbit hole on this case. In this week's episode, Ashley discusses the disappearance and murder of 17-year-old Brian Carrick. He disappeared from Johnsburg, IL in 2002 and to this day the case is still technically unsolved. Thank you to listener Jillian for submitting this story! Join us as we explore the dark side of humanity. Resources: 1. 20/20 Episode Season 7 Ep. 2: The Mystery on Johnsburg Road 2. https://abcnews.go.com/US/happened-br...

This week, Kat tells us all about the Twin Flames Universe and its leaders Jeff & Shaleia Divine. It's an interesting, still changing story that will hopefully make you go and watch the two awesome docuseries about them! There's so much more to the story, but this is a good start. So, grab a drink and join us! References: Inside the Twin Flames Universe and Its Always Online, All-Consuming World | Vanity Fair Inside the Toxic World of 'Twin Flames' Spirituality (vice.com) Watch Escaping Twin F...