New episode every Thursday!

Season 5

June 22, 2023

S. 5 Episode 36- The Disappearance of Brian Shaffer

Resources : https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/us-news/mystery-student-who-went-bar-29365303 https://armchairdetective.medium.com/the-strange-disappearance-of-brian-shaffer-b617f8c2a0d https://thecrimewire.com/true-crime/The-Bizar...

Episode page
June 15, 2023

Carl Panzram & His Life of Pain, Hatred & Killing

In this week's episode, Kat covers one of America's worst serial killers. One of the best examples of "he never stood a chance," Kat dives deep into the life of Carl Panzram - responsible for the killing of at least …

Episode page
June 9, 2023

S. 5 Episode 34- The Bear Brook Murders, aka the Allenstown Four

The Bear Brook Murders, also referred to as the Allenstown Four. There were four female murder victims that were discovered inside barrels in the woods of Allenstown, New Hampshire. Two in 1985 and two in 2000. Join us as we …

Episode page
June 1, 2023

The Alligator Man and The Candy Lady: Texan Urban Legends

In this week's episode, Kat tells us about two urban legends out of Texas - The Alligator Man and The Candy Lady. Blurring the line between what was real and what was just the imagination of local folks, it's easy …

Episode page
May 26, 2023

S. 5 Episode 30- The Soham Murders of Holly Wells and Jessica Chapman

In this episode Ashley discusses the Soham murders of 10 year old best friends Holly Wells and Jessica Chapman. This case was solved in an interesting manner that we hadn't heard of before! After the story we discuss a little...

Episode page
May 18, 2023

S. 5 Episode 31 - Starvation Heights

In this episode, Kat tells us all about Dr. Linda Hazzard - a "fasting doctor" without a medical degree who practiced what she believed was a cure-all treatment: fasting for weeks or months, giving enemas for hours every day,...

Episode page
May 12, 2023

S. 5 Episode 30- The Michigan Murderer aka the Co-Ed Killer

Trigger warnings for this episode: Rape; gruesome descriptions of deaths Everyone has heard of serial killers like Ted Bundy. Handsome, charming, the type of guy no one would expect to be a serial killer…that’s exactly how ma...

Episode page
April 20, 2023

S. 5 Episode 28 - The Luchadora Serial Killer!!

Tune in to hear Kat tell us all about Mexico's very "first" serial killer who was caught in 2005. You are reading that right, folks! Kat does a deep dive into La Mataviejitas (Sp. "The Little Old Lady Killer") sentenced …

Episode page
April 6, 2023

S. 5 Episode 27- Unsolved Missing Case of Morgan Nick

Morgan Nick was just 6 years old when disappeared from a little league baseball field in 1988 and was never seen or heard from again. To this day her case remains unsolved, however, her mother has never given up hope. …

Episode page
Feb. 9, 2023

S. 5 Episode 26- The Disappearance of Kathy Stobaugh

It's our 4 year anniversary! Ashley retells her very first story she ever did that includes more details and updates than the first time around! In this episode we cover the missing case of Kathy Stobaugh, the wife of Charle...

Episode page
Feb. 2, 2023

S. 5 Episode 25- Leap Castle

In this episode, Kat covers what some call Ireland's Most Haunted Castle: Leap Castle. Said to have been built sometime between 1250 and the early 1500s on ancient Druid ceremonial land, this location has its fair share of mu...

Episode page
Jan. 19, 2023

S. 5 Episode 24- The Murder of Randi Lee Trimble

In this week's episode Ashley discusses the real life horror film that led to the murder of Randi Lee Trimble. We also discuss the organizations that Randi's mother has created in her honor. Join us as we explore the dark …

Episode page
Jan. 5, 2023

S. 5 Episode 23- The Moors Murders - Ian Brady and Myra Hindley

This week, Kat tells the story of The Moors Murders, a killing spree carried out by Ian Brady and Myra Hindley between July 1963 and October 1965 in and around Manchester, England. Their five victims, all children, were Pauli...

Episode page
Dec. 15, 2022

S. 5 Episode 22- Disappearance of 9 year old Stephanie Crane

In this episode Ashley discusses the October 11, 1993 disappearance of Stephanie Crane, who was last seen only 500 yards from her home. Over 1000 people searched for her and her case remains open to this day. If you have …

Episode page
Dec. 8, 2022

S. 5 Episode 21 - Dr. Death - The Story of Christopher Duntsch

This week, Kat talks about Dr. Christopher Duntsch -- or, as he is more commonly called now, "Dr. Death." In a two short years, Duntsch left a trail of destruction and death in his wake. It was a total system …

Episode page
Nov. 17, 2022

S. 5 Episode 20- - The Curse/Mystery of the Oak Island Money Pit

Look guys--- you know I can't pronounce words correctly most of the time. It's not intentional, it's just how it is. ~Ashley In this week's episode Ashley discusses Oak Island and the mystery back story of supposed buried pir...

Episode page
Nov. 10, 2022

S. 5 Episode 19- The Shanley Hotel

In this week's episode, Kat and Ashley didn't give me a description, so the producer is g-g-ghost writing for them! I think this episode is about the Shanley Hotel, which sounds like a Walmart version of the Stanley Hotel, do...

Episode page
Oct. 27, 2022

S. 5 Episode 18- Crazy Crimes Committed on Halloween

This week's episode covers all kinds of crazy crimes that were committed on Halloween throughout the years. Join us as we explore the dark side of humanity! Resources: 1. https://thoughtcatalog.com/jim-goad/2014/10/13-brutal...

Episode page
Oct. 24, 2022

S. 5 Episode 17 - Domestic Violence Awareness Month w/ Melissa

This week's episode is coming in late due to unforeseen technical issues, but that makes Case Files with Kat & Ashley, Case Files with Kat & Ashley!! We apologize that part of the episode is not included - especially the …

Episode page
Oct. 6, 2022

S. 5 Episode 16- The Mothman Folklore

In this week's episode Ashley discusses the folklore of the Mothman. You may be familiar with the Mothman Prophecies film and this is the backstory. Join us as we explore the dark side of humanity! Resources: 1. https://themo...

Episode page
Sept. 22, 2022

S. 5 Episode 15- Michelle 'Shelly' Knotek- America's Most Evil Mom

In this week's episode, Kat covers the story of Michelle Shelley Knotek who is known for abusing her children and torturing and killing her friends. She is rightfully referred to as "America's Most Evil Mom". Join us as we ex...

Episode page
Sept. 15, 2022

S. 5 Episode 14- The Blood House of Atlanta, GA

In this week's episode Ashley discusses the bleeding house of Atlanta, Georgia and all of the craziness that followed suit in 1987. The case remains unsolved to this day. Resources: 1. https://www.trulyadventure.us/blood-hous...

Episode page
Sept. 8, 2022

S. 5 Episode 13- Jennifer Schuett- Survivor (guest interview)

The story of how an 8 year old was kidnapped, raped, stabbed, and left to die in 1990 - and lived to talk about it and solve her own case. References: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/jennifer-schuett-case-afraid-of-the-dark-texa...

Episode page
Sept. 1, 2022

S. 5 Episode 12- The Experiments of Unit 731

In this episode, Ashley discusses the horrific experiments that the Japanese Unit 731 performed on civilians during WWII. Learn about the experiments, the aftermath, and what is happening now. Join us as we explore the dark s...

Episode page