New episode every Thursday!

Season 5

Oct. 6, 2022

S. 5 Episode 16- The Mothman Folklore

In this week's episode Ashley discusses the folklore of the Mothman. You may be familiar with the Mothman Prophecies film and thi…

Episode page
Sept. 22, 2022

S. 5 Episode 15- Michelle 'Shelly' Knotek- America's Most Evil Mom

In this week's episode, Kat covers the story of Michelle Shelley Knotek who is known for abusing her children and torturing and k…

Episode page
Sept. 15, 2022

S. 5 Episode 14- The Blood House of Atlanta, GA

In this week's episode Ashley discusses the bleeding house of Atlanta, Georgia and all of the craziness that followed suit in 198…

Episode page
Sept. 8, 2022

S. 5 Episode 13- Jennifer Schuett- Survivor (guest interview)

The story of how an 8 year old was kidnapped, raped, stabbed, and left to die in 1990 - and lived to talk about it and solve her …

Episode page
Sept. 1, 2022

S. 5 Episode 12- The Experiments of Unit 731

In this episode, Ashley discusses the horrific experiments that the Japanese Unit 731 performed on civilians during WWII. Learn a…

Episode page
Aug. 25, 2022

S. 5 Episode 11- Interview with survivor of Harold Camping's Doomsday…

In episode 1 of season 5 Kat covered Harold Camping's teachings and his end of the world predictions, the aftermath and what is h…

Episode page
Aug. 11, 2022

S. 5 Episode 10- Amish Serial Killer Eli Stuzman Jr.

This week Kat discusses Eli Stutzman Jr. -- he was born into an Amish community in Apple Creek, OH, on September 20, 1950. Stutz…

Episode page
Aug. 4, 2022

S. 5 Episode 9- The Disappearance of Phoenix Coldon

In this week's episode Ashley discusses the disappearance of Phoneix Coldon, a 23 year old woman who went missing under very stra…

Episode page
July 28, 2022

S. 5 Episode 8- Murder of Baby James

In this week's episode we have a special guest who joined us! Kat discusses the story of two ten year old boys who kidnapped and …

Episode page
July 14, 2022

S. 5 Episode 7- Listener Stories and 150th Episode Celebration

This week, we celebrate our 150th episode!! We play some great voicemails, we have a guest host, listener stories, and more!

Episode page
July 7, 2022

S. 5 Episode 6- From Miss Irresistible to Life in Prison

In this week's episode Ashley talks about the case of Christine Paolilla. She was once voted as Miss Irresistible by fellow stude…

Episode page
June 30, 2022

S. 5 Episode 5- The Disappearance of Brittany Wood and It's Aftermath

In this episode Kat discusses the disappearance of Brittany Wood and all that her disappearance exposed, including an incestuous …

Episode page
June 2, 2022

S. 5 Episode 2- The Hauntings of Emily Morgan Hotel

In this week's episode Ashley talks about the Emily Morgan Hotel, voted in 2015 as one of the top three most haunted hotels in th…

Episode page
May 26, 2022

S. 5 Episode 1- Harold Camping and the End of the World

In the season 5 opening episode Kat takes us through Harold Camping's teachings and his end of the world predictions, the afterma…

Episode page