New episode every Thursday!

Episodes

Aug. 11, 2022

S. 5 Episode 10- Amish Serial Killer Eli Stuzman Jr.

This week Kat discusses Eli Stutzman Jr. -- he was born into an Amish community in Apple Creek, OH, on September 20, 1950. Stutz…

Episode page
Aug. 4, 2022

S. 5 Episode 9- The Disappearance of Phoenix Coldon

In this week's episode Ashley discusses the disappearance of Phoneix Coldon, a 23 year old woman who went missing under very stra…

Episode page
July 28, 2022

S. 5 Episode 8- Murder of Baby James

In this week's episode we have a special guest who joined us! Kat discusses the story of two ten year old boys who kidnapped and …

Episode page
July 14, 2022

S. 5 Episode 7- Listener Stories and 150th Episode Celebration

This week, we celebrate our 150th episode!! We play some great voicemails, we have a guest host, listener stories, and more!

Episode page
July 7, 2022

S. 5 Episode 6- From Miss Irresistible to Life in Prison

In this week's episode Ashley talks about the case of Christine Paolilla. She was once voted as Miss Irresistible by fellow stude…

Episode page
June 30, 2022

S. 5 Episode 5- The Disappearance of Brittany Wood and It's Aftermath

In this episode Kat discusses the disappearance of Brittany Wood and all that her disappearance exposed, including an incestuous …

Episode page
June 23, 2022

S. 5 Episode 4- Where is Katelin Akens?

In this week's episode, Ashley discusses the 2015 disappearance of 19 year old Katelin Akens who was last seen by her ex-stepfath…

Episode page
June 9, 2022

S. 5 Episode 3- Ivan Milat, Australia's Backpacker Murderer

In this week's episode Kat tells us all about Ivan Milat, more famously known as Australia's Backpacker Murderer! She discusses h…

Episode page
June 2, 2022

S. 5 Episode 2- The Hauntings of Emily Morgan Hotel

In this week's episode Ashley talks about the Emily Morgan Hotel, voted in 2015 as one of the top three most haunted hotels in th…

Episode page
May 26, 2022

S. 5 Episode 1- Harold Camping and the End of the World

In the season 5 opening episode Kat takes us through Harold Camping's teachings and his end of the world predictions, the afterma…

Episode page
May 5, 2022

S. 4 Episode 40- Debby and Mark Constantino: Paranormal Rockstars, Do…

This week Ashley discusses Debby and Mark Constantino, paranormal rockstars. They were EVP experts for Ghost Adventures and were …

Episode page
April 28, 2022

S. 4 Episode 39- Israel Keys Part 2

Kat wraps up her two part series on the insane story of serial killer Israel Keys this week. Join us as we explore the dark side …

Episode page
April 21, 2022

S. 4 Episode 38- Israel Keys Pt. 1

Israel Keyes was an American serial killer, bank robber, burglar, arsonist, kidnapper, rapist, and necrophile who murdered a mini…

Episode page
April 14, 2022

S. 4 Episode 37- The Russian Sleep Experiment and other Creepy Pastas

In this week's episode Kat tells us some of her favorite Creepy Pasta stories including the Russian Sleep Experiment! References:…

Episode page
April 7, 2022

S. 4 Episode 36- Katherine Knight: The Female Hannibal Lecter

In this week's episode Ashley discusses Katherine Knight, the first woman in Australia to be sentenced to life without parole. Sh…

Episode page
March 24, 2022

S. 4 Episode 35- Haunted History of Ashton Villa

In this week's episode we recap our adventures on the Haunted Tavern Pop Up event at the haunted Ashton Villa in Galveston then K…

Episode page
March 10, 2022

S. 4 Episode 34- Daniel LaPlante's Rein of Horror

In this week's episode we cover Daniel LaPlante. LaPlante was a troubled teenage boy that began with petty theft and quickly esca…

Episode page
March 3, 2022

S. 4 Episode 33- The Murder of Mackenzie Cowell

In this week's episode Kat covers the murder of 17 year old Mackenzie Cowell. This was a story suggested by one of our listeners …

Episode page
Feb. 24, 2022

S. 4 Episode 32- Disappareance of Brandy Hanna

In this week's episode Ashley discusses the unsolved case of Brandy Hanna, a 32 year old waitress from Charleston, SC. Her ex lov…

Episode page
Feb. 17, 2022

S. 4 Episode 31- 10 Creepy Valentine's Day Mysteries

In this episode we cover a list from 2016 of 10 creepy and bizarre Valentine's Day mysteries-- and we give updates on the ones th…

Episode page
Feb. 3, 2022

S. 4 Episode 30- The Katie Beers Story

In this episode Ashley discusses the abduction of 9 year old Katie Beers by a family friend. She was already suffering abuse at h…

Episode page
Jan. 27, 2022

S. 4 Episode 29- All Things Ouija Board

This week Kat tells all about the interesting history of the Ouija Board!! How it was originally used, how it became popular (and…

Episode page
Jan. 20, 2022

S. 4 Episode 28- All things Tarot

In this episode Ashley discusses all things tarot! She discusses the history of tarot cards, how to pick a deck, how to prepare t…

Episode page
Jan. 13, 2022

S. 4 Episode 27- Murder of Junko Furuta

In this week's episode Kat discusses the 44 days of Hell that Junko Furuta went through before being murdered. Junko was a 17 yea…

Episode page