Episodes

On October 18, 2003, Brandon Rumbaugh and Lisa Gurrieri were discovered tragically murdered in the back of a white F-150 truck near Bumble Bee, Arizona. The young couple, celebrating their first anniversary, had planned an overnight camping trip to stargaze, but were found shot multiple times. The case remains unsolved to this day. This episode explores the heartbreaking story of Lisa and Brandon, the theories and how to file a report if you have any information. Resources: https://the-m-files.m...

In this episode, Kat dives into the jaw-dropping story of William Allen Jordan —a master manipulator who spun an intricate web of lies across continents. Posing as a CIA operative, Jordan lured multiple women into marriage, fathered children, and drained their finances, all while maintaining overlapping relationships. Kat unpacks Jordan’s timeline of deception, exploring how he convinced intelligent, successful women to believe his dangerous lies. But this isn’t just a story of broken hearts—Jor...

In this week's episode Ashley discusses the disappearance of Bethany Markowski who was only 11 at the time of her disappearance. Her father claims she walked into the mall but she was never seen entering and has never been since. Join us as we discuss the background history of this family, the disappearance, the investigation and what has happened since. Bethany's case is still unsolved and open. Resources: Jackson Police Department at (731) 425-8400. Tennessee Bureau of Investigation at +1 (800...

In this episode of Case Files with Kat & Ashley , Kat dives into the chilling case of Dan Wozniak—a struggling actor who committed two brutal murders in a desperate attempt to fund his wedding. What started as a plan to steal from his friend, Afghanistan war veteran Sam Herr, quickly spiraled into a gruesome double homicide that shocked Orange County. We’ll take you through every twisted detail about his crimes and how his fiancée, Rachel Buffett, became entangled in the investigation. Was she a...

Brittany Willis was a 17-year-old high school student living in Wilson, NC. Two days shy of her 18th birthday, on June 28, 2004 she was kidnapped, raped and murdered. In this episode, we discuss what happened, the suspects, the trials that dragged on, and the wonderful way the community now honors her memory. Resources : https://www.wral.com/story/wake-jury-to-hear-high-profile-case-in-wilson/3973556/ https://www.wral.com/story/3173257/ https://abc11.com/archive/6660636/ https://restorationnewsm...

What happens when a career con artist is handed a golden ticket to crime—by the FBI? In this episode, Kat dives into the twisted, mind-blowing story of Scott Lee Kimball—a fraudster, serial killer, and FBI informant who used his connections to manipulate, deceive, and kill while hiding in plain sight. Kimball convinced the FBI that he was a trusted informant, gaining early release from prison and free rein to roam the country. But instead of stopping criminals, he became one of the most dangerou...

On June 7, 1992, three women—Suzanne Streeter (19), her mother, Sherrill Levitt (47), and friend Stacy McCall (18)—vanished from their home in Springfield, Missouri, without a trace. Their purses, cars, cigarettes, and money were left behind, and there was no sign of struggle. Despite extensive searches and countless theories, the case remains unsolved over 30 years later. What happened to the Springfield Three? Join us as we explore the dark side of humanity. Resources: https://en.wikipedia.org...

Becky was just 41 years old when, on the afternoon of Feb. 23, 2023, her own father discovered her lifeless on the bathroom floor of her Quincy, Illinois, home. She had been dead for hours — shot a total of 14 times. None of the wounds were immediately fatal. What happened to Becky? Why was her father the one to find her? It’s honestly a really sad story and one that was sort of publicly foreshadowed by her murderer, on national TV. Join us as we explore the dark side of humanity. Resources: htt...

Part 2: In Part 2 of our deep dive into the twisted tale of T. Cullen Davis, we pick up where the drama left off—unpacking the shocking courtroom battles, surprising twists, and ultimate verdict that stunned the nation. With accusations of murder, betrayal, and greed swirling, Cullen Davis's trial became one of the most sensational legal sagas in Texas history. We examine the explosive testimony, the high-profile legal maneuvers, and the shadow of Cullen’s immense wealth that loomed over the pro...

Part 1: In this gripping episode of Case Files with Kat and Ashley , we unravel the scandalous and shocking story of T. Cullen Davis, the Texas oil heir whose life of luxury, controversy, and crime captured national headlines. Known as the "Richest Man Ever Tried for Murder," Davis's dramatic fall from grace is a tale of wealth, power, and alleged deadly intent. Join us as we dig into the evidence, the colorful characters involved, and the legacy of a case that continues to fascinate and divide....

This week we discuss the disappearance of Suzanne Lyall, a 19 year old college student who went missing from the SUNY Albany campus. She went missing on March 2, 1998 and has never been heard from again. Who used her ID? Who used her ATM card? Where did she go? We also discuss all the wonderful, amazing advocacy her parents did to create laws to support other families of missing people. Welcome to 2025! Resources: 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disappearance_of_Suzanne_Lyall 2. https://icestat...

Before we take a 2 week break for the holidays and travel, we wanted to leave you with a story that happened on Christmas Eve in 1945. It a devastating fire that consumed the Sodder family home in Fayetteville, West Virginia. While George and Jennie Sodder and four of their children escaped, five of their children seemingly vanished without a trace. The official explanation claimed they perished in the fire, but troubling inconsistencies and chilling clues have kept the mystery alive for nearly ...

In this episode Ashley discusses the unsolved, bizarre 1935 murder case of Ronald T. Owen aka Artemus Ogletree. There are so many unanswered questions, so many twists and turns and at this point we may never know who did it or why! Join us as we explore the dark side of humanity. And as always, if you see something, please say something. Resources: 1. https://fox2now.com/news/missouri/unsolved-mystery-the-haunting-case-of-room-1046/ 2. https://www.murdershetold.com/episodes/artemus-ogletree 3. h...

In this episode, Kat dives into the chilling story of the 2009 Thanksgiving massacre. What was meant to be a warm family gathering turned into a nightmare when Paul Merhige, an estranged relative, arrived unannounced and unleashed unimaginable violence on his own family. We’ll explore the details of that fateful day, the heartbreaking impact on survivors, and the controversial courtroom battles that followed. Join us as we unravel the shocking events and complex family dynamics that led to this ...

In this week's episode Ashley discusses the 2011 unsolved murder of 23 year old Ashland man, David Grubbs. What seems like a completely random murder has terrified the community even through today. The police department however continues to search any and all leads. If you have any information please contact the following: Ashland Police Department at 541-482-5211 or the APD Anonymous Tip Line at 541-552-2333. You can also call or text Crime Stoppers of Southern Oregan at 1-800-850-0580 refer to...

In part two of our deep dive into the Bamber Family murders, the story gets crazy. Was the real killer ever caught, or has an innocent man paid the price for a crime he didn't commit? Join Kat as she explores the unsettling twists and growing doubts that keep this case in the spotlight, and challenges the conviction that shocked a nation. REFERENCES: https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2024/08/05/did-the-uks-most-infamous-family-massacre-end-in-a-wrongful-conviction?_sp=164fd6a7-5bdc-439c-8dcc-77...

HAPPY HALLOWEEN!!! In this week's episode Ashley does a deep dive about Ronald O'Bryan, the man who ruined Halloween aka THE Candy Man. Ronald was convicted of poisoning his own son with cyanide. Learn about the actual chain of events, the reason why and the aftermath. Join us as we explore the dark side of humanity! Resources: 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ronald_Clark_O%27Bryan 2. https://people.com/candy-man-killer-timothy-obryan-murder-8732896 3. https://www.aetv.com/real-crime/the-man-wh...

A horrifying night ends in the deaths of five family members. Two people could have committed the crime—one is dead, and the other is behind bars. But was justice truly served, or is this another case of a wrongful conviction? Join Kat as she delves into the chilling Bamber Family murders at White House Farm in Essex, England, unraveling the twists and doubts surrounding one of the UK's most infamous cases. PS. Thanks for your patience as Kat got through Gala season! PPS. If you'd liek to give t...

In this episode Ashley discusses the story of Susan Walters Kuhnhausen. Her husband sent a hitman to kill her but instead, she killed him. Join us as we explore her story, the aftermath and what she's doing now. Resources: 1. https://www.wweek.com/news/2016/08/17/a-hit-man-came-to-kill-susan-kuhnhausen-she-survived-he-didnt/ 2. https://www.wave3.com/story/7051831/oregon-woman-kills-hitman-hired-by-her-husband/ 3. https://blurredbylines.com/articles/susan-kuhnhausen-walters-survivor-hitman-portla...

In this week's episode, Kat & Ashley are joined by Melissa - the Outreach, Education, & Prevention Director w/ Bay Area Turning Point to talk about all things cyberstalking. In honor of Domestic Violence Awareness Month, we thought the best way to handle this is to bring in an expert & try to bring education to all of you so you could pass it on. FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center: https://www.ic3.gov/ Stalking Prevention, Awareness, Statistics & Resource Center (SPARC): https://www.stalkingawa...

In part 2 Ashley discusses Holly's history, her relationship with Jesse, the actual crime and how all of these organizations and adults failed these victims to the fullest extent. Always remember the names of: Rylee Elizabeth Allen, Michael James Mayo, Tiffany Dore Guess, Ivy Webster and Brittany Brewer. Resources: 1. Body of Crime: Henryetta Mass Murders: Monster- Jesse Lee McFadden 2. https://kfor.com/news/local/unchecked-sin-required-checks-for-jesse-mcfadden-only-show-basic-information-was-r...

In this episode Ashley details the criminal history of Jesse McFadden, the man responsible for the Henryetta mass murder. Once you learn about his history you too will be left wondering how in the hell was this man free to walk around and why was he allowed around these children. Part 2 will cover Holly's history and the actual tragedy. Resources: 1. Body of Crime: Henryetta Mass Murders: Monster- Jesse Lee McFadden 2. https://kfor.com/news/local/unchecked-sin-required-checks-for-jesse-mcfadden-...

We can't respond, so if you have specific questions, message us on FB! Welcome to Part 2 of the Long Island Serial Killer (LISK) or the Gilgo Beach Killer story, and we are joined again by Sarah Sarah! This is a HUGE & WILD story - but it's important to remind everyone that we want to honor the victims & their loved ones of this case. With that being said, this episode starts with the discovery that an architect named Rex Huermann is allegedly responsible for the deaths of so many of the victims...

We can't respond, so if you have specific questions, message us on FB! This week, Kat and Ashley are joined by Sarah Sarah! (FInally!) Kat kicks off a two-part series on the gripping investigation into the Long Island Serial Killer (LISK) and his eventual capture after decades of eluding justice. Grab a drink, because the story is intense. From a corrupt police force to the neglect of the victims' stories, this case is brimming with drama and dark twists. PS. If you messaged us about the Brian C...